Compare calculators

Both calculators run independently — change the inputs on either side to compare results.

Retirement Withdrawal Strategy Calculator

Determine how much to withdraw from each retirement account — taxable, traditional IRA, and Roth — to meet your annual income need efficiently. Useful when coordinating withdrawals across multiple account types.

Traditional IRA/401(k) Balance ($)

Roth IRA Balance ($)

Taxable Investment Accounts ($)

Annual Income Need ($)

Tax Rate on Withdrawals (%)

Fill in the required fields to see your result.

Retirement

4% Rule Retirement Withdrawal Calculator

Estimate how much you can safely withdraw from your retirement portfolio each year. Use this when planning annual retirement income to avoid outliving your savings.

Total Portfolio Value ($)

Withdrawal Rate (%)

Tax Rate on Withdrawals (%)

Fill in the required fields to see your result.

Key differences

	Retirement Withdrawal Strategy Calculator	4% Rule Retirement Withdrawal Calculator
Category	Retirement	Retirement
Inputs required	5	3
Result	Recommended Annual Withdrawal ($)	Safe Annual Withdrawal (After Tax) ($)
What it does	Determine how much to withdraw from each retirement account — taxable, traditional IRA, and Roth — to meet your annual income need efficiently. Useful when coordinating withdrawals across multiple account types.	Estimate how much you can safely withdraw from your retirement portfolio each year. Use this when planning annual retirement income to avoid outliving your savings.